Loading...

Lesson: Challenging Critical/Logical Reasoning - 23t01

Additional Question Types: Correlation/Causation, continued

[Page 23 of 24]

If too much pressure is exerted on the bottom shelf of a bookcase, the entire bookcase will collapse. Sherry's bookcase has collapsed. Therefore, too much pressure must have been exerted on its bottom shelf.

Which one of the following criticisms best describes a weakness in the argument above?

It supports its conclusion with irrelevant evidence.
It contains a shift in the meaning of the word "collapse" from "partial collapse" to "full collapse."
It concludes that an outcome has been caused by a particular factor that may be only one possible cause of the outcome in question.
It overlooks the possibility that some bookshelves have only one shelf.
It draws an overly broad conclusion from contradictory evidence.

The evidence tells us that exerting too much pressure on the bottom shelf of a bookcase is sufficient to make the bookcase collapse. But that doesn't mean it's the only thing that would cause a bookcase to collapse. Lots of things could — an earthquake perhaps. So the fact that the bookcase has collapsed does not mean that we can conclude someone must have exerted too much pressure on the shelf. As Choice (C) says, that's one possible cause of the outcome in question.

Back Next

Next to display next topic in the chapter.

Video Lessons and 10 Fully Explained Grand Tests

Large number of solved practice MCQ with explanations. Video Lessons and 10 Fully explained Grand/Full Tests.

Current Menu
More for You
All in this Category

You may be interested in

Colleges in cities of Balochistan

Comprehensive lists of colleges in ...

Colleges in Hydrabad

Find a comprehensive list of major ...

Study Abroad

How to go Abroad to study in a repu ...

Fellowships News

Havw latest Fellowships News in you ...

SAT-Subject Physics

Lessons and practice questions with ...

GRE: Graduate Record Examination

Know what is GRE - Geeneral test an ...

Career in Agriculture

Universities offering programs in A ...

FMH - Mdecal Degrees

FMH College of Medicine & Dentistry ...